Prevailing Employers Can Recover Costs

  • Dedication & Experience

    Representing clients in Southern California since 1925!

    What We Do
  • SoCal Blog: Stay Informed

    Read about developments in the law & how they may affect you.

    Recent News
  • Proven Track Record

    View the recent verdicts & settlements we've won.

    Our Results
  • Take the First Step Now

    Get help now! Use our quick contact form to email us.

    Free Case Review

Prevailing Employers Can Recover Costs

On August 11, 2011, in Plancich v. United Parcel Service, Inc., (California Courts of Appeal – 4th District, No. E050631) Plancich sued UPS making several claims including failure to provide overtime compensation. The trial court and jury found in favor of UPS and the court also awarded costs to UPS. Plancich made a motion to strike the award of costs. The law Plancich relied on for his overtime claim grants attorney fees and costs to a prevailing employee but makes no mention of employers creating a one way recovery Planich argued. (Labor Code §1194). The trial court agreed and granted Plancich's motion because granting costs to the prevailing employer would render the law useless and be against public policy by having a "chilling effect on workers who have had their statutory rights violated." UPS appealed this ruling.

The appeals court found that the trial court's granting the motion to strike was not proper and UPS was entitled to move for costs. They found that the lower court's ruling was not correct because the law Plancich relied on is silent as to prevailing employer's recovery so Code of Civil Procedure § 1032 allows prevailing employers to recover costs because they were not expressly excepted from recovery. The court also found that this doesn't make Labor Code § 1194 meaningless because it still allows prevailing employees to recover attorney fees. The court couldn't consider whether this ruling would have a chilling effect on employee lawsuits because "the plain meaning of the statute governs the outcome."
Categories: Wage and Hour Claims
  • Dedication & Experience

    Representing clients in Southern California since 1925!

    What We Do
  • SoCal Blog: Stay Informed

    Read about developments in the law & how they may affect you.

    Recent News
  • Proven Track Record

    View the recent verdicts & settlements we've won.

    Our Results
  • Take the First Step Now

    Get help now! Use our quick contact form to email us.

    Free Case Review
Spray, Gould & Bowers LLP - Orange County Lawyers
Located at 2 Corporate Park, Suite 201
Irvine, CA 92606.
View Map
Phone: (888) 427-8064
Website:
© 2017 All Rights Reserved.

Southern California's Law Firm

Since 1925

Contact our office to recieve a FREE case evaluation.

Call Now 888.427.8064
Internet Marketing Experts The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.